Dear Atty. Gab,
Musta Atty! I’m writing to you from our town, San Mateo, Isabela. We just had our local elections, and there’s a lot of confusion regarding the mayoralty results, and I hope you can shed some light on this for us ordinary citizens.
Our situation is this: The leading candidate for Mayor, Mrs. Elena Santiago (from Partido Masipag), withdrew her candidacy about two weeks before election day. This happened because her husband, who was running for Congressman, suddenly passed away, and she decided to file as his substitute candidate for Congress. A few days after she withdrew, specifically on May 5, 2024, Partido Masipag nominated Mr. Ricardo Cruz as her substitute for Mayor. He filed his Certificate of Candidacy (COC) immediately.
The problem is, the official ballots were already printed with Mrs. Santiago’s name. During the election on May 13, 2024, Mrs. Santiago’s name garnered the highest number of votes, around 15,200. The Municipal Board of Canvassers (MBOC) initially proclaimed her, but then quickly issued another Certificate of Proclamation for Mr. Cruz, crediting him with the 15,200 votes. However, the second-place candidate, Mr. Jose Garcia (from Partido Magiting), who got 12,800 votes, is protesting. He claims Mr. Cruz’s substitution was invalid because he heard there was a COMELEC deadline last December 2023 for substituting candidates who withdrew. He argues that since Mr. Cruz wasn’t a valid substitute, he (Mr. Garcia) should be declared the winner as the highest-ranking eligible candidate.
We are very confused, Atty. Who is the rightful mayor? Can votes for a withdrawn candidate be transferred to a substitute filed so late? Doesn’t the law allow substitution until election day? What happens now?
Thank you for your guidance.
Respectfully,
Armand Jimenez
Dear Armand Jimenez,
Thank you for reaching out. I understand the confusion surrounding the recent mayoral election results in San Mateo, Isabela. The situation you described involves complex rules on candidate substitution in Philippine elections, especially concerning deadlines set by the Commission on Elections (COMELEC) for automated polls.
The core issue revolves around the validity of Mr. Ricardo Cruz’s substitution for Mrs. Elena Santiago. While the Omnibus Election Code generally allows substitution until midday of election day under certain circumstances, the COMELEC, particularly for automated elections requiring early ballot printing, has the authority to set specific, earlier deadlines for substitutions arising from voluntary withdrawal. If Mr. Cruz’s substitution, prompted by Mrs. Santiago’s withdrawal, occurred after the COMELEC-mandated deadline for such cases, his candidacy might indeed be invalid. Consequently, votes cast for Mrs. Santiago could not legally be credited to him, potentially altering the election outcome.
Untangling the Rules: Candidate Substitution Deadlines and Their Effects
Navigating the rules on candidate substitution requires understanding the interplay between the general provisions of the Omnibus Election Code (OEC) and specific resolutions issued by the COMELEC, especially in the context of automated elections. The OEC provides the foundational rule regarding substitution.
Sec. 77. Candidates in case of death, disqualification or withdrawal of another. – If after the last day for the filing of certificates of candidacy, an official candidate of a registered or accredited political party dies, withdraws or is disqualified for any cause, only a person belonging to, and certified by, the same political party may file a certificate of candidacy to replace the candidate who died, withdrew or was disqualified. The substitute candidate nominated by the political party concerned may file his certificate of candidacy for the office affected in accordance with the preceding sections not later than mid-day of the day of the election. (Batas Pambansa Blg. 881, Omnibus Election Code, Emphasis supplied)
Based solely on this provision, it might seem that Mr. Cruz’s filing on May 5, 2024, being before midday of election day (May 13, 2024), was timely. However, the advent of automated elections necessitated adjustments. Republic Act No. 9369 amended election laws to accommodate the technical requirements of automation, including the early printing of official ballots. To ensure the integrity and efficiency of this system, the law empowered COMELEC to set necessary deadlines.
“For this purpose, the Commission shall set the deadline for the filing of certificate of candidacy/petition of registration/manifestation to participate in the election.” (Sec. 13, Republic Act No. 9369, amending Sec. 11 of R.A. 8436 [now Sec. 15])
Pursuant to this authority, COMELEC typically issues resolutions establishing specific timelines for election-related activities, including candidate substitution. Crucially, these resolutions often differentiate between the reasons for substitution. For the May 2010 elections, for instance, COMELEC Resolution No. 8678 set different deadlines:
“The substitute for a candidate who withdrew may file his certificate of candidacy as herein provided for the office affected not later than December 14, 2009.
The substitute for a candidate who died or suffered permanent incapacity or disqualified by final judgment, may file his certificate of candidacy up to mid-day of election day.” (Section 13, COMELEC Resolution No. 8678 [Note: This is an example resolution; the specific resolution for the 2024 election cycle would govern your case, but likely contains similar distinctions])
The rationale for this distinction is clear: withdrawal is a voluntary act, allowing candidates and parties ample time to adjust before ballot printing. Conversely, death or disqualification can occur unexpectedly, necessitating a later deadline extending closer to election day. In your scenario, Mrs. Santiago withdrew her candidacy for Mayor to substitute her deceased husband for Congress. The trigger for the mayoral substitution vacancy was her withdrawal, not death or disqualification from the mayoral race. Therefore, the deadline applicable to Mr. Cruz’s substitution as mayor would likely be the earlier one set by COMELEC for withdrawals, which you heard was in December 2023.
If Mr. Cruz filed his COC after this specific deadline for withdrawal-based substitutions, his substitution is generally considered invalid. An invalid substitution means he was not a legitimate candidate. Consequently, the votes cast for Mrs. Santiago (whose name remained on the ballot) cannot be legally transferred or credited to him. These votes are considered stray votes for the specific position of Mayor.
When the apparent winner’s candidacy is deemed void ab initio (from the beginning), as in the case of an invalid substitution filed before the election, the principle is that the candidate who obtains the highest number of valid votes among the qualified candidates should be proclaimed the winner. The votes for the invalid candidate are disregarded.
“There being no valid substitution, the candidate with the highest number of votes should be proclaimed as the duly elected mayor.” [Paraphrased principle derived from jurisprudence concerning invalid substitutions where the remaining qualified candidate wins.]
In your situation, if Mr. Cruz’s substitution was indeed invalid because it missed the COMELEC deadline for withdrawals, then the 15,200 votes for Mrs. Santiago cannot be counted for him. The only remaining qualified candidates are Mr. Garcia and any others who ran. Mr. Garcia, having obtained 12,800 votes, would then be the candidate with the highest number of valid votes among the qualified contenders and should rightfully be proclaimed mayor. The argument that the second-placer cannot win does not typically apply when the ‘winner’ was never a valid candidate in the first place due to failing qualification requirements or invalid substitution before the election occurred.
Practical Advice for Your Situation
- Verify the Deadline: Confirm the exact deadline set by the relevant COMELEC Resolution for the 2024 elections regarding substitutions due to voluntary withdrawal. This is the crucial first step.
- Substitution Validity is Key: Understand that the central issue is whether Mr. Cruz’s substitution was filed by the deadline specifically set for withdrawals. If not, his candidacy is likely void.
- Votes are Not Transferable: Votes cast for a candidate whose substitute is invalidly filed are generally considered stray for that specific position and cannot be credited to the purported substitute.
- Highest Qualified Candidate Wins: If Mr. Cruz is deemed not a valid candidate, the winner is the qualified candidate who received the most votes. In your description, this appears to be Mr. Garcia.
- Protest is the Proper Remedy: Mr. Garcia’s protest before the COMELEC is the correct legal avenue to challenge the proclamation based on the alleged invalid substitution.
- MBOC Actions: The MBOC’s act of issuing a second proclamation for Mr. Cruz, especially if done without clear COMELEC authority or proper procedure after the first proclamation for Mrs. Santiago, can be questioned and potentially annulled by COMELEC.
- Await COMELEC Decision: The final determination of who the rightful mayor is rests with the COMELEC, and potentially the courts if the decision is appealed. Community members should await the official resolution of the protest.
- Distinguish Reasons for Substitution: Remember the critical difference in deadlines based on the reason for substitution (withdrawal vs. death/disqualification). Mrs. Santiago’s reason for withdrawing (to substitute her husband) does not change the fact that the mayoral vacancy arose from her withdrawal, triggering the earlier deadline for that specific substitution.
The situation highlights the importance of adhering strictly to election timelines and rules established by COMELEC, particularly in automated elections. While the intent of the voters who chose Mrs. Santiago might be relevant in a broader sense, election law mandates adherence to procedural requirements for a substitution to be valid and for votes to be counted correctly.
Hope this helps!
Sincerely,
Atty. Gabriel Ablola
For more specific legal assistance related to your situation, please contact me through gaboogle.com or via email at connect@gaboogle.com.
Disclaimer: This correspondence is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific legal guidance tailored to your situation, please schedule a formal consultation.

Leave a Reply