Can a Shipping Company Be Held Liable If My Buyer Fails to Pay?

Dear Atty. Gab,

Musta Atty! I hope you can shed some light on a very frustrating situation I’m facing with my export business. I run a small company in Pampanga that makes and exports custom furniture. A few months ago, we secured a sizeable order from a new client in Long Beach, California, worth about $25,000.

As per our usual practice for new clients, the payment term was telegraphic transfer upon the vessel’s arrival. To secure our payment, we held on to the original Bill of Lading. My understanding has always been that the shipping company cannot release the cargo to the buyer (the consignee) without them presenting this original document. This was my only leverage.

The goods arrived in California, but the payment never came. After weeks of unanswered emails and calls to the buyer, I contacted the shipping line’s agent here in Manila. To my shock, they informed me that the cargo had already been released to the buyer! They said the buyer executed an ‘Indemnity Agreement’ or a ‘Letter of Guarantee,’ promising to hold the shipping line harmless for releasing the container without the original Bill of Lading.

I feel completely betrayed by the system. What is the point of a Bill of Lading if the carrier can just bypass it? The buyer has disappeared, and my small business is now out $25,000. Is the shipping company liable for my loss? Can I sue them for releasing my products without the document I was holding as security? I feel they failed in their duty to protect my interest.

Hoping for your guidance.

Sincerely,
Julius Salazar

Dear Julius Salazar,

Thank you for reaching out. I understand how distressing and financially damaging this situation must be for your business. It is a common misconception that a bill of lading is an absolute guarantee that prevents a carrier from releasing goods. While it serves as a crucial document, Philippine commercial law provides for circumstances where a carrier can release cargo to the consignee without its surrender.

Your situation involves two distinct legal relationships: your contract of sale with the buyer and your contract of carriage with the shipping company. The carrier’s primary duty under the contract of carriage is to transport the goods and deliver them to the person named as the consignee. Their responsibility does not typically extend to enforcing the payment terms of your separate sales agreement. While it feels unjust, the carrier’s actions may not necessarily translate to legal liability on their part, especially if they followed established commercial practices.

The Bill of Lading: A Contract of Carriage, Not a Payment Guarantee

The core of your issue lies in the nature and function of a bill of lading. Legally, it is defined as a written acknowledgment of the receipt of goods and an agreement to transport and deliver them to a specified person or their order. It is the primary evidence of the contract between you (the shipper) and the carrier. The terms stipulated within it, provided they are not contrary to law or public policy, govern the rights and liabilities of both parties in relation to the transportation of the goods.

You believe the carrier was obligated to release the goods only upon the surrender of the original bill of lading. However, unless this is explicitly and mandatorily stated in the bill of lading’s terms, the carrier is not necessarily bound by such a strict requirement. In many standard bills of lading, the language often says the document must be surrendered ‘if required by the carrier,’ giving them discretion. More importantly, our laws provide a specific exception. The Code of Commerce, which governs contracts of carriage by sea, directly addresses this scenario.

In case the consignee, upon receiving the goods, cannot return the bill of lading subscribed by the carrier, because of its loss or any other cause, he must give the latter a receipt for the goods delivered, this receipt producing the same effects as the return of the bill of lading. (Article 353, Code of Commerce)

The phrase ‘or any other cause’ is broad and has been interpreted by courts to include situations like the one you’ve described, where the consignee cannot produce the bill of lading because the shipper is retaining it pending payment. The Indemnity Agreement or Letter of Guarantee your buyer provided to the carrier essentially serves as the ‘receipt’ mentioned in the law, protecting the carrier from claims arising from the release of the cargo. By accepting this guarantee, the carrier is operating within the allowances of the law.

This highlights a critical distinction between two separate contracts. Your agreement with the buyer is a contract of sale. The carrier is not a party to this contract and therefore cannot be held responsible for the buyer’s failure to pay you. The carrier’s agreement with you is a contract of carriage, and their primary duty is to deliver the goods to the consignee in good condition.

The contract between [the shipper] and [the carrier] is a contract of carriage of goods; hence, [the carrier’s] liability should be pursuant to that contract and the law on transportation of goods. Not being a party to the contract of sale between [the shipper] and [the buyer], [the carrier] cannot be held liable for the payment of the value of the goods sold.

Your argument that the carrier failed to exercise extraordinary diligence under the Civil Code (Articles 1733-1735) also does not typically apply here. This standard of care pertains to the carrier’s responsibility to prevent the loss, destruction, or deterioration of the goods during transport. In your case, the goods were not lost or damaged; they were delivered to the correct recipient (the consignee). The issue is not one of improper handling of the cargo, but of the terms of its release, which is governed by the specific provisions of the Code of Commerce.

There is no obligation, therefore, on the part of [the carrier] to release the goods only upon the surrender of the original bill of lading.

Law and jurisprudence have established that the surrender of the original bill of lading is not an absolute condition for a carrier to be discharged of its contractual obligation. The Indemnity Agreement effectively shifted the risk from the carrier to the consignee, who guaranteed to answer for any claims (like yours) that might arise from the release. Therefore, while the carrier is likely not liable to you, your primary legal recourse for the non-payment of the goods lies directly with the buyer who received them.

Practical Advice for Your Situation

  • Review Your Bill of Lading: Check the exact wording on the bill of lading. Does it contain a strict, mandatory clause requiring its surrender, or does it say surrender is ‘if required by the Carrier’? This wording is crucial.
  • Primary Legal Action: Your strongest legal claim is against your buyer in California for breach of the contract of sale. You should focus your resources on pursuing payment directly from them.
  • Future Payment Security: For new or untrusted buyers, relying on the retention of the bill of lading is risky. For future transactions, insist on more secure payment methods like a Letter of Credit (L/C) issued by a reputable bank. An L/C guarantees payment once you present the required shipping documents (including the bill of lading) to the bank, effectively eliminating the risk of non-payment by the buyer.
  • The Role of the Indemnity Agreement: Understand that the indemnity agreement is a standard and valid commercial instrument. It protects the carrier, and your claim is now effectively against the buyer who made that guarantee.
  • Consult International Trade Lawyers: Pursuing a claim against a foreign entity can be complex. You should consult with a law firm specializing in international trade and collections to explore your options for suing the buyer in their jurisdiction.
  • Notify the Carrier Formally: Although they may not be liable, send a formal demand letter to the carrier and their agent, putting your claim on record. They can, in turn, use this to formally demand payment from the buyer under the indemnity agreement.
  • Re-evaluate Your Risk Management: Use this unfortunate experience to reassess your company’s credit and risk policies for international sales. Implement stricter background checks and payment terms for new clients.

While the law may not favor your claim against the shipping company, it fully supports your right to collect payment from the buyer. The path forward is to pursue them for the value of the goods they received.

Hope this helps!

Sincerely,
Atty. Gabriel Ablola

For more specific legal assistance related to your situation, please contact me through gaboogle.com or via email at connect@gaboogle.com.

Disclaimer: This correspondence is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific legal guidance tailored to your situation, please schedule a formal consultation.

About the Author

Atty. Gabriel Ablola is a member of the Philippine Bar. Gaboogle is his personal blog where he shares legal analysis and commentary on Philippine law, covering areas such as Maritime Law, Corporate Law, Taxation Law, and Constitutional Law.

For professional legal services and inquiries, Atty. Ablola may be reached through ASG Law Partners at www.asglawpartners.com or gca@asglawpartners.com.

Other Posts

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *