TL;DR
The Supreme Court ruled that Shang Properties did not commit unfair competition by using the mark “ST. FRANCIS” for its real estate developments, even though St. Francis Development Corporation had been using a similar mark. The Court found “ST. FRANCIS” to be geographically descriptive, referring to the location of both developers’ projects in the Ortigas Center area, specifically near St. Francis Street and Avenue. Geographically descriptive marks are not automatically protectable unless they acquire a ‘secondary meaning’ – a strong public association with a specific source. Because St. Francis Development Corporation failed to prove this secondary meaning for their “ST. FRANCIS” mark outside of Ortigas Center, they could not prevent Shang Properties from using it. This case clarifies that businesses cannot claim exclusive rights over geographically descriptive terms without demonstrating a strong, widespread brand recognition that transcends mere location.
Ortigas Turf War: When Naming Rights Collide in Real Estate Development
In the bustling Ortigas Center, a prime commercial district in Metro Manila, two real estate giants clashed over the seemingly simple name “ST. FRANCIS.” St. Francis Development Corporation (SFDC), developer of the St. Francis Square Commercial Center, sought to prevent Shang Properties Realty Corporation from using “ST. FRANCIS TOWERS” and “ST. FRANCIS SHANGRI-LA PLACE” for their own projects in the same vicinity. SFDC claimed prior use and goodwill associated with the “ST. FRANCIS” mark, arguing that Shang Properties’ use constituted unfair competition. This case reached the Supreme Court, posing a critical question: Can a business claim exclusive rights to a geographically descriptive mark without proving it has acquired a secondary meaning, effectively turning a common location name into a protected brand?
The legal battle began in the Intellectual Property Office (IPO), where SFDC filed complaints for unfair competition and opposition to Shang Properties’ trademark applications. The IPO’s Bureau of Legal Affairs (BLA) initially sided with SFDC on unfair competition regarding “THE ST. FRANCIS TOWERS” but later decisions and appeals led to conflicting rulings. The IPO Director-General eventually reversed the BLA, finding “ST. FRANCIS” to be geographically descriptive and thus not exclusively appropriable by SFDC. The Court of Appeals (CA), however, sided with SFDC, finding unfair competition and emphasizing SFDC’s established goodwill and the doctrine of secondary meaning. Shang Properties then elevated the case to the Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court’s analysis hinged on Section 168 of the Intellectual Property Code (IP Code), which defines unfair competition. The Court emphasized that unfair competition requires fraud – an intent to deceive the public into believing that one’s goods or services are those of another. Crucially, the Court stated that protection against unfair competition under Section 168.1 extends to those who have established goodwill, whether or not they have a registered mark. However, merely having goodwill for a geographically descriptive mark does not automatically equate to fraud when another party uses a similar mark in the same geographic area.
The Court referenced Section 168.2, highlighting the core definition of unfair competition:
“[a]ny person who shall employ deception or any other means contrary to good faith by which he shall pass off the goods manufactured by him or in which he deals, or his business, or services for those of the one having established such goodwill, or who shall commit any acts calculated to produce said result x x x.”
The Supreme Court underscored that the “true test” of unfair competition is “whether the acts of the defendant have the intent of deceiving or are calculated to deceive the ordinary buyer.” This requires proving fraud or intent to deceive. In this case, the Court found this element lacking. The CA’s error, according to the Supreme Court, was in assuming SFDC had an exclusive right to the “ST. FRANCIS” mark. The Court clarified that “ST. FRANCIS” is a geographically descriptive mark. Referring to US jurisprudence, the Court explained that such terms are in the “public domain,” meaning sellers should be free to indicate the geographic origin of their goods or services. A geographically descriptive term identifies a location like continents, nations, regions, cities, or even streets.
The decision then delved into the concept of secondary meaning. For a geographically descriptive mark to become protectable, it must acquire secondary meaning, meaning the public associates the mark not just with a place, but specifically with a particular source of goods or services. Section 123.2 of the IP Code outlines the requirements for establishing secondary meaning:
“the secondary meaning must have arisen as a result of substantial commercial use of a mark in the Philippines; (b) such use must result in the distinctiveness of the mark insofar as the goods or the products are concerned; and (c) proof of substantially exclusive and continuous commercial use in the Philippines for five (5) years before the date on which the claim of distinctiveness is made.”
SFDC, despite using the mark since 1992, only demonstrated use within Ortigas Center. The Court found this insufficient to establish secondary meaning nationwide. Without secondary meaning, and absent proof of fraudulent intent by Shang Properties to deceive customers into thinking their developments were SFDC’s, the claim of unfair competition failed. The Court also noted Shang Properties’ use of the well-known “Shangri-La” brand, further diminishing the likelihood of consumer confusion. Ultimately, the Supreme Court reinstated the IPO Director-General’s decision, exonerating Shang Properties from unfair competition. This ruling reinforces the principle that geographically descriptive terms remain in the public domain unless a robust secondary meaning, demonstrably linking the mark to a specific source nationwide, is established. The case clarifies the boundaries of trademark protection for geographically descriptive marks and the necessity of proving fraudulent intent to establish unfair competition.
FAQs
| What is a geographically descriptive mark? | It’s a mark that primarily describes the geographic origin of goods or services, like a place name. |
| Why are geographically descriptive marks generally not protectable? | Because they are considered to be in the public domain, allowing all businesses in that area to use them to describe their location. |
| What is ‘secondary meaning’ in trademark law? | It’s when a geographically descriptive mark becomes strongly associated with a specific company’s goods or services in the public mind, beyond just the location. |
| What did St. Francis Development Corp. fail to prove? | They failed to prove that their “ST. FRANCIS” mark had acquired secondary meaning nationwide, beyond just the Ortigas Center area. |
| What is the key element needed to prove unfair competition? | Fraudulent intent – demonstrating that the alleged infringer intended to deceive the public into thinking their goods/services were from the original mark holder. |
| What was the Supreme Court’s ruling in this case? | The Supreme Court ruled in favor of Shang Properties, stating they did not commit unfair competition because “ST. FRANCIS” was geographically descriptive and SFDC did not prove secondary meaning or fraudulent intent. |
For inquiries regarding the application of this ruling to specific circumstances, please contact Atty. Gabriel Ablola through gaboogle.com or via email at connect@gaboogle.com.
Disclaimer: This analysis is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific legal guidance tailored to your situation, please consult with a qualified attorney.
Source: Shang Properties Realty Corporation v. St. Francis Development Corporation, G.R. No. 190706, July 21, 2014

Leave a Reply