Dear Atty. Gab,
Musta Atty! I’m a seafarer who recently received a favorable decision from the NLRC for my permanent disability claim against my former manning agency. The NLRC ordered them to pay me around P3.5 million. Shortly after, the company’s lawyer contacted my lawyer to arrange the payment. They said it was to prevent the sheriff from seizing their assets, as we had already filed for a writ of execution.
When I received the check, they made me sign a document called a “Satisfaction of Judgment” and a separate “Receipt of Payment.” I noticed a clause that said the payment was “without prejudice to the company’s Petition for Certiorari pending with the Court of Appeals.” My lawyer said this was standard procedure, but I’m getting worried. Some of my colleagues told me that since I already accepted the money, the case is completely finished and I have nothing to worry about. However, another friend said the company can still win their appeal and I might be forced to return the entire P3.5 million.
I am now very confused and anxious. Does my acceptance of the payment mean the case is over for good? Or is it possible that I will have to give the money back if the Court of Appeals rules in the company’s favor? I’m afraid to spend any of it because of this uncertainty. I hope you can enlighten me on this matter.
Sincerely,
Mario Rivera
Dear Mario,
Thank you for your email. I understand your anxiety and confusion regarding the payment you received. It is a common source of concern for many who find themselves in a similar situation, where a judgment award is paid while an appeal is still pending.
To put it simply, your colleagues are mistaken. Accepting payment under a document that explicitly contains a “without prejudice” clause does not automatically terminate the case. This phrase legally preserves the company’s right to continue with its appeal. You are correct to be cautious, as there is a possibility that you may be ordered to return the amount you received if the Court of Appeals, and subsequently the Supreme Court, reverses the NLRC’s decision. Let’s delve into why this is the case.
The ‘Without Prejudice’ Clause: Understanding Conditional Settlements
What you and your former employer entered into is essentially a form of conditional settlement. In Philippine law, parties are encouraged to enter into a compromise agreement to avoid or put an end to a lawsuit. A compromise agreement is a contract between the parties, and as long as its terms are not contrary to law, morals, good customs, public order, or public policy, it is considered valid and binding. Once approved, it generally has the force and effect of a final judgment, a concept known as res judicata.
However, because a compromise is a contract, the parties have the freedom to stipulate terms and conditions that modify its effects. The Supreme Court has clarified this principle:
“After all, a compromise agreement is still a contract by nature, and as such, the parties are free to insert clauses to modify its legal effects, so long as such modifications are not contrary to law, morals, good customs, public order, or public policy.”
In your situation, the inclusion of the “without prejudice” clause is a critical modification. It signals that the payment is not an admission of final defeat by the company. Instead, it is a practical step taken to prevent the immediate and disruptive effects of a writ of execution, which could involve the seizure of their bank accounts or properties. By making the payment conditional, the company ensures that their right to question the NLRC’s decision in a higher court is not waived.
The Supreme Court has tackled this very issue, distinguishing between settlements that are absolute and those that are conditional. The key factor is fairness and whether the agreement preserves the rights of both parties. An agreement that allows the employer to appeal but forces the employee to waive all future claims would be seen as prejudicial and may be interpreted as a final settlement. Conversely, an agreement that is fair to both parties will be upheld based on its explicit terms.
The Court has held that an employee who signs a receipt with a “without prejudice” clause is prevented from claiming the case is closed, especially when the agreement is balanced. Consider this ruling:
“This Court disagreed with the CA and held that final and executed decisions of the NLRC did not prevent the CA from reviewing the same under Rule 65 of the Rules of Court. It was further ruled that the employee was estopped from claiming that the case was closed and terminated, considering that the employee’s Acknowledgment Receipt stated that such was without prejudice to the final outcome of the petition for certiorari pending before the CA.”
This means the legal battle is not yet over. The most important part of the documents you signed is likely a clause on restitution. This is an undertaking on your part to return the money should the judgment be reversed. The Court has recognized the validity of such arrangements, especially when they explicitly reference the NLRC’s rules on restitution.
“That I understand that in case of reversal and/or modification of the Decision and the Resolution… of the NLRC by the Court of Appeals and/or the Supreme Court, I shall return whatever is due and owing to shipowners/manning agents without need of further demand.”
This type of clause makes the agreement fair because it provides a remedy for both parties. You received the judgment award early, and the company preserves its right to recover the payment upon a favorable outcome in its appeal. Therefore, your fear is legally grounded. The case is not moot and academic, and the possibility of having to return the money is real and dependent entirely on the final outcome of the company’s petition for certiorari.
Practical Advice for Your Situation
- Review the Documents Thoroughly: Ask your lawyer for a copy of the “Satisfaction of Judgment” and any other documents you signed. Pay close attention to clauses mentioning “without prejudice,” “restitution,” or the possibility of a reversal by a higher court.
- Understand the ‘Without Prejudice’ Nature: Internalize that this phrase means the legal proceedings are ongoing. The payment you received is not a final prize but a conditional award pending the outcome of the appeal.
- Be Financially Prudent: Your instinct not to spend the money is wise. It is highly advisable to set aside a significant portion, if not all, of the amount in a secure account until the case is fully and finally resolved by the highest court.
- Monitor the Appeal: Stay in close contact with your lawyer and regularly ask for updates on the status of the company’s Petition for Certiorari at the Court of Appeals. The case is far from over.
- Recognize the Purpose of the Payment: Understand that the company did not pay you out of goodwill. They paid to comply with an NLRC order and to stop a writ of execution, which can be damaging to their operations. The payment was a calculated business decision, not a surrender.
- Acknowledge the Restitution Obligation: Be mentally and financially prepared for the possibility of having to return the funds. The documents you signed likely create a legal obligation for you to do so if the decision is overturned.
- Prepare for a Long Process: Appeals in the Court of Appeals and the Supreme Court can take years. Patience and careful financial planning are essential during this waiting period.
Your situation highlights a complex but common procedure in labor litigation. While receiving the judgment award provides immediate financial relief, the conditional nature of the payment means the finality of your case is still uncertain. Continue to work closely with your legal counsel to navigate the next stages of the appeal.
Hope this helps!
Sincerely,
Atty. Gabriel Ablola
For more specific legal assistance related to your situation, please contact me through gaboogle.com or via email at connect@gaboogle.com.
Disclaimer: This correspondence is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific legal guidance tailored to your situation, please schedule a formal consultation.

Leave a Reply