TL;DR
The Supreme Court declared that a ‘right to top’ provision in a government contract, which allowed a private company to surpass the highest bidder in the sale of public assets, is invalid. This ruling reinforces the principle of competitive public bidding, ensuring fairness and maximizing public benefit in government transactions. The Court emphasized that such rights, if not based on a pre-existing legitimate interest in the specific asset, undermine the level playing field intended by public bidding laws, even if the government might initially receive a slightly higher price.
Leveling the Playing Field: Why ‘Right to Top’ Provisions Fail in Public Bidding
Imagine a public auction where, after the highest bidder is announced, a favored participant gets a special privilege to simply outbid everyone else by a fixed margin. This scenario encapsulates the contentious ‘right to top’ provision at the heart of Osmena v. PSALM. Senator Osmeña III challenged the legality of this clause, arguing it undermined the fundamental principle of competitive public bidding mandated for the privatization of government assets. The case revolved around the sale of the Naga Power Plant Complex (NPPC) by the Power Sector Assets and Liabilities Management Corporation (PSALM), a government entity tasked with privatizing power assets.
The controversy arose because SPC Power Corporation (SPC) held a ‘right to top’ stemming from a previous Land Lease Agreement (LBGT-LLA) related to a smaller, adjacent power plant. This right allowed SPC to exceed the winning bid for the NPPC by 5%, effectively securing the deal even though Therma Power Visayas, Inc. (TPVI) had initially submitted the highest bid. PSALM defended its decision, citing legal opinions and the potential for a higher sale price due to SPC’s exercised right. However, the Supreme Court scrutinized whether this contractual advantage for SPC violated the sacrosanct principle of public bidding.
The Court began its analysis by affirming the importance of certiorari as the proper remedy to address grave abuse of discretion by government instrumentalities, particularly when actions contravene constitutional principles or laws. It underscored PSALM’s mandate under the Electric Power Industry Reform Act (EPIRA) of 2001 (R.A. No. 9136) to privatize assets through transparent and open public bidding to optimize value for the government. The implementing rules of EPIRA explicitly state:
(d) All assets of NPC shall be sold in an open and transparent manner through public bidding, and the same shall apply to the disposition of IPP contracts;
The Court also addressed the issue of legal standing, acknowledging Senator Osmeña’s right to bring the suit. While his position as a legislator and committee chairperson might not automatically grant standing, the Court invoked the doctrine of transcendental public interest. Given the significant public concern surrounding the privatization of power assets and ensuring fair competition, the Court deemed it appropriate to relax procedural rules and allow the petition to proceed.
Turning to the core issue, the Court delved into the nature of the ‘right to top’ provision itself. While acknowledging the validity of rights of first refusal in certain private contracts, particularly when supported by consideration within a lease agreement, the Court distinguished the context of public bidding. It cited precedents like JG Summit Holdings, Inc. v. Court of Appeals, which upheld a ‘right to top’ in a specific context where it did not undermine competitive bidding and benefited the government. However, the crucial distinction in Osmena was the lack of a legitimate, pre-existing interest of SPC in the NPPC itself. SPC’s right stemmed from a lease agreement for a different property, the Land-Based Gas Turbine (LBGT), not the NPPC.
The Supreme Court contrasted this case with Power Sector Assets and Liabilities Management Corporation v. Pozzolanic Philippines Incorporated, where a right of first refusal was invalidated for future contracts because it preempted future bidding processes. In Pozzolanic, the right was deemed to have no valid basis as the object of the right was still inexistent at the time of the original bidding. The Court reasoned that valid rights of first refusal, and by extension, rights to top, are typically rooted in a beneficiary’s existing interest in the specific property, such as a tenant’s interest in leased land or a shareholder’s interest in company shares.
In Osmena, the Court found SPC’s asserted interest—concerns about security or operational requirements due to the proximity of the NPPC to its LBGT facility—insufficient to justify the ‘right to top.’ The Court emphasized that the NPPC, a significantly larger power complex, was not merely incidental to SPC’s existing operations. Allowing SPC to exercise the ‘right to top’ in this scenario, the Court concluded, undermined the principle of equal opportunity in public bidding and potentially discouraged other bidders, even if it resulted in a marginally higher immediate price for the government. As the Court stated, referencing LTFRB v. Stronghold Insurance Company:
…a ‘right of first refusal’, or ‘right to top,’ whether granted to a bidder or non-bidder, discourages other parties from submitting bids, narrowing the number of possible bidders and thus preventing the government from securing the best bid.
Ultimately, the Supreme Court declared the ‘right to top’ provision in the LBGT-LLA void and annulled the sale of the NPPC to SPC. This decision serves as a significant reaffirmation of the paramount importance of competitive public bidding in government contracts and the necessity for any exceptions, like rights of first refusal or to top, to be narrowly construed and firmly grounded in legitimate, pre-existing interests related to the specific subject of the bidding.
FAQs
| What was the central legal issue in this case? | The core issue was whether a ‘right to top’ provision in a government contract, allowing a company to outbid the highest bidder, violated the principle of competitive public bidding. |
| What is a ‘right to top’? | A ‘right to top’ is a contractual clause that allows a party to surpass the highest bid submitted by another party, typically by a predetermined margin (in this case, 5%). |
| Why did the Supreme Court invalidate the ‘right to top’ in this case? | The Court invalidated it because SPC’s ‘right to top’ was not based on a legitimate, pre-existing interest in the Naga Power Plant Complex itself and undermined the policy of competitive public bidding. |
| What is the significance of ‘public bidding’ in government contracts? | Public bidding is a crucial mechanism to ensure transparency, fairness, and the best possible value for the government in the procurement of goods, services, and privatization of assets. |
| Did SPC offer a higher price for the power plant? | Yes, SPC exercised its ‘right to top’ and offered a price that was 5% higher than the original highest bidder, TPVI. However, this was not enough to validate the ‘right to top’ clause itself. |
| What is the practical implication of this ruling? | This ruling reinforces that government agencies must prioritize competitive public bidding and that contractual advantages like ‘rights to top’ will be strictly scrutinized and invalidated if they undermine fair competition, especially when not tied to a direct, pre-existing interest in the asset being bid upon. |
For inquiries regarding the application of this ruling to specific circumstances, please contact Atty. Gabriel Ablola through gaboogle.com or via email at connect@gaboogle.com.
Disclaimer: This analysis is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific legal guidance tailored to your situation, please consult with a qualified attorney.
Source: Osmena III v. PSALM, G.R. No. 212686, September 28, 2015

Leave a Reply