Tag: Unrestricted Retained Earnings

  • Is the ‘Premium’ on a Share Buyback Taxable as a Dividend?

    Dear Atty. Gab

    Musta Atty!

    I hope you can shed some light on a situation I’m currently facing. I am a minority shareholder in a family-owned manufacturing business, “Hizon Innoventures Corp.,” based in Laguna. For the past five years, the company has been struggling with its finances and has not declared any dividends, which I understood completely given the circumstances. We’ve been operating on a deficit, according to the last family meeting.

    Recently, the board decided to streamline operations and offered to buy back some of my preferred shares to improve the company’s capital structure. I agreed, and they paid me an amount that was higher than my original investment. The total payment was P500,000, where P400,000 was my original capital (par value) and P100,000 was a ‘premium’ for the redemption.

    To my surprise, the company’s accountant informed me that a final withholding tax was deducted from the P100,000 premium, treating it as a dividend payment. I’m very confused by this. How can the company pay a ‘dividend’ when it has no profits or retained earnings to speak of? I thought dividends could only come from profits. Is it correct for them to tax this premium as if it were a dividend? It feels more like a gain from selling my shares back to them, not a distribution of company earnings.

    I would be very grateful for your guidance on this matter. Thank you for your time.

    Sincerely,
    Maria Hizon

    Dear Maria,

    Thank you for your email. It’s completely understandable why you’re confused, as the distinction between a return of capital and a distribution of profits can be complex. Your intuition is correct to question the nature of the payment, especially given your company’s financial situation.

    The core principle here is straightforward: for a payment from a corporation to its shareholder to be legally considered a dividend for tax purposes, it must be sourced from the corporation’s unrestricted retained earnings. If the company has been operating at a deficit and has no available earnings for distribution, any amount paid to you for the redemption of your shares—including the ‘premium’—is generally not a dividend. It is more accurately characterized as part of the payment for the shares you surrendered. Let’s explore the legal basis for this.

    When a Payout is Not a Dividend: The Unrestricted Retained Earnings Rule

    The foundation of your query lies in the legal definition of a dividend and the corporate power to declare it. Under Philippine law, these two concepts are inextricably linked. The National Internal Revenue Code (NIRC) is very clear about what constitutes a dividend for tax purposes.

    Section 73 (A). Definition of Dividends. – The term ”dividends” when used in this Title means any distribution made by a corporation to its shareholders out of its earnings or profits and payable to its shareholders, whether in money or in other property.

    This definition explicitly states that a dividend must come from a corporation’s “earnings or profits.” This is not just a tax concept; it is a fundamental rule of corporate governance, reinforced by the Corporation Code. The law prevents a company from distributing assets to shareholders if it would impair its capital, which is held in trust for the protection of its creditors. The power to declare dividends is strictly limited to profits that are not allocated for any other corporate purpose, known as unrestricted retained earnings.

    Section 43. Power to Declare Dividends. – The board of directors of a stock corporation may declare dividends out of the unrestricted retained earnings which shall be payable in cash, in property, or in stock to all stockholders on the basis of outstanding stock held by them… (Batas Pambansa Bilang 68, The Corporation Code of the Philippines)

    Therefore, if Hizon Innoventures Corp. indeed has no unrestricted retained earnings and is in a deficit position as you mentioned, its board of directors has no legal power to declare dividends. Any payment designated as such would be improper. The ‘premium’ of P100,000 you received is not a dividend but part of the total redemption price for your shares. It is a component of the gain you realized from the disposition of your capital asset (the shares), not a distribution of corporate profits.

    Jurisprudence distinguishes between an ordinary dividend and a distribution in liquidation or redemption. An ordinary dividend is a recurring return on one’s investment, while a redemption payment is a one-time transaction where you surrender your stock, effectively ending your interest as a shareholder for those shares.

    “The distinction between a distribution in liquidation and an ordinary dividend is factual; the result in each case depending on the particular circumstances of the case and the intent of the parties. If the distribution is in the nature of a recurring return on stock it is an ordinary dividend. However, if the corporation is really winding up its business or recapitalizing and narrowing its activities, the distribution may properly be treated as in complete or partial liquidation and as payment by the corporation to the stockholder for his stock.”

    Since you surrendered your shares in exchange for the P500,000, the transaction is not a recurring return but a sale. The gain from this sale (Redemption Price of P500,000 less your original cost of P400,000 = P100,000) should be treated as a capital gain, which is subject to a different tax regime—not the final withholding tax on dividends. Since the tax was erroneously withheld, a claim for refund is the proper remedy. The law provides a two-year window to file this claim, starting from the date the tax was paid to the BIR.

    Section 229. Recovery of Tax Erroneously or Illegally Collected. – No suit or proceeding shall be maintained in any court for the recovery of any national internal revenue tax hereafter alleged to have been erroneously or illegally assessed or collected… until a claim for refund or credit has been duly filed with the Commissioner; … In any case, no such suit or proceeding shall be filed after the expiration of two (2) years from the date of payment of the tax or penalty…

    This means a formal claim must be filed with the BIR within two years. You do not need to wait for the BIR to act on it before going to the Court of Tax Appeals, especially if the two-year period is about to expire. The key is that the claim was erroneously collected because the underlying payment was not a dividend in the first place.

    Practical Advice for Your Situation

    • Verify the Company’s Financials: As a shareholder, you have the right to inspect corporate records. Politely request a copy of the company’s most recent Audited Financial Statements (AFS). Check the Statement of Retained Earnings to confirm if there are any “Unrestricted Retained Earnings.” This document is your primary evidence.
    • Communicate with the Accountant: Discuss your findings with the company accountant. Show them the legal definition of dividends and the requirement of unrestricted retained earnings. It’s possible they made a conservative but incorrect interpretation.
    • Discuss the Refund Process: The company, as the withholding agent, is the proper party to file the refund claim with the BIR for the tax it erroneously remitted. Urge them to initiate this process.
    • Understand the Tax Difference: The tax on dividends (e.g., 10% final tax for individuals) is different from the capital gains tax on the sale of shares not traded on a stock exchange (15% of the net capital gain). Clarifying this can help explain why the ‘dividend’ classification is incorrect.
    • Mind the Deadline: Take note of the exact date the tax was remitted to the BIR. The two-year period to file a refund claim under Section 229 of the NIRC is non-extendible. Do not let it lapse.
    • Document Everything: Keep records of the share redemption agreement, proof of payment, the withholding tax return filed by the company, and all your correspondence on this matter.
    • Seek Formal Counsel: Your situation involves specific financial data and documents. It would be best to consult with a tax lawyer or a certified public accountant who can review everything and provide formal advice or representation.

    In summary, the ‘premium’ you received is not a taxable dividend if your company has no unrestricted retained earnings. The tax was likely withheld in error, and you or your company should pursue a refund.

    Hope this helps!

    Sincerely,
    Atty. Gabriel Ablola

    For more specific legal assistance related to your situation, please contact me through gaboogle.com or via email at connect@gaboogle.com.

    Disclaimer: This correspondence is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific legal guidance tailored to your situation, please schedule a formal consultation.

  • Dissenting Stockholders’ Rights: Unrestricted Retained Earnings as a Prerequisite for Payment

    TL;DR

    The Supreme Court ruled that dissenting stockholders cannot demand immediate payment for their shares unless the corporation has sufficient unrestricted retained earnings at the time the lawsuit is filed. In this case, stockholders Philip and Elnora Turner dissented from an amendment to Lorenzo Shipping Corporation’s articles of incorporation and sought payment for their shares. The Court emphasized that the corporation’s obligation to pay only arises when unrestricted retained earnings are available, protecting corporate creditors. This decision clarifies that stockholders’ appraisal rights are contingent upon the financial health of the corporation, ensuring that creditors are prioritized before stockholders in the distribution of assets. Therefore, a premature lawsuit filed before the corporation has sufficient retained earnings will be dismissed, safeguarding the corporation’s financial stability and protecting creditors’ interests.

    Locked Out: When Can Dissenting Shareholders Demand Their Due?

    Philip and Elnora Turner, holding 1,010,000 shares in Lorenzo Shipping Corporation, opposed an amendment removing stockholders’ pre-emptive rights. Exercising their appraisal rights, they demanded payment of P2.276 per share, totaling P2,298,760.00. However, Lorenzo Shipping refused, citing a deficit of P72,973,114.00 and asserting that payment could only be made if there were unrestricted retained earnings. The disagreement led to an appraisal committee, which valued the shares at P2.54 each, totaling P2,565,400.00. Despite this valuation, Lorenzo Shipping still refused to pay, leading the Turners to file a collection suit in the Regional Trial Court (RTC). The central legal question is whether the dissenting stockholders’ right to demand payment accrues even if the corporation lacks unrestricted retained earnings at the time the lawsuit is filed.

    The RTC initially ruled in favor of the Turners, ordering Lorenzo Shipping to pay. However, the Court of Appeals (CA) reversed this decision, holding that the Turners’ cause of action had not yet accrued because Lorenzo Shipping lacked unrestricted retained earnings when the suit was filed. The Supreme Court (SC) affirmed the CA’s decision, emphasizing the importance of the trust fund doctrine. This doctrine dictates that a corporation’s assets are held in trust for the payment of its creditors, who must be prioritized over stockholders. This means that corporate creditors must be paid before any distribution of assets can be made to stockholders.

    The right of appraisal, as outlined in Section 81 of the Corporation Code, allows dissenting stockholders to demand payment for their shares when they oppose certain corporate actions. These actions include amendments to the articles of incorporation that alter stockholders’ rights, the sale of substantially all corporate assets, and mergers or consolidations. However, Section 41 of the Corporation Code stipulates that a corporation can only acquire its own shares if it has unrestricted retained earnings to cover the purchase. This is in line with the trust fund doctrine, protecting creditors from the risk of the corporation depleting its assets to buy back shares.

    The Supreme Court underscored that a cause of action requires the existence of a legal right, a correlative legal duty, and a violation of that right. In this case, while the Turners had a legal right to dissent and demand payment, Lorenzo Shipping’s duty to pay only arose when it had unrestricted retained earnings. Since Lorenzo Shipping had a deficit at the time the lawsuit was filed, there was no violation of the Turners’ rights, and therefore, no cause of action. The court cited established jurisprudence stating that “an action commenced before the cause of action has accrued is prematurely brought and should be dismissed.”

    Section 82 of the Corporation Code states, “That no payment shall be made to any dissenting stockholder unless the corporation has unrestricted retained earning in its books to cover such payment.”

    The Court rejected the RTC’s interpretation that the existence of unrestricted retained earnings after the demand was sufficient. The Supreme Court clarified that the Turners’ right of action had to exist at the time the lawsuit was filed. The subsequent accumulation of unrestricted retained earnings did not retroactively validate the premature lawsuit. This ruling emphasizes the importance of adhering to procedural requirements and ensuring that all elements of a cause of action are present before initiating legal proceedings. It further clarifies that while the right to appraisal exists, its enforcement is contingent upon the financial status of the corporation.

    FAQs

    What was the key issue in this case? The key issue was whether dissenting stockholders could demand payment for their shares when the corporation lacked unrestricted retained earnings at the time the lawsuit was filed.
    What is the trust fund doctrine? The trust fund doctrine states that a corporation’s assets are held in trust for its creditors, who must be prioritized in the distribution of assets before any payments are made to stockholders.
    What is the right of appraisal? The right of appraisal allows dissenting stockholders to demand payment for their shares when they oppose certain fundamental corporate actions, such as amendments to the articles of incorporation.
    What are unrestricted retained earnings? Unrestricted retained earnings are profits that a corporation can freely distribute to its stockholders without impairing its capital or its ability to pay its creditors.
    Why is the existence of unrestricted retained earnings important in this case? The existence of unrestricted retained earnings is a prerequisite for a corporation to purchase its own shares from dissenting stockholders, ensuring the protection of corporate creditors.
    What happens if a corporation does not have unrestricted retained earnings? If a corporation lacks unrestricted retained earnings, it cannot legally pay dissenting stockholders for their shares until sufficient earnings are available.
    What was the court’s ruling in this case? The court ruled that the dissenting stockholders’ lawsuit was premature because the corporation did not have unrestricted retained earnings at the time the suit was filed, thus dismissing the case.

    In conclusion, this case reaffirms the importance of the trust fund doctrine and clarifies the conditions under which dissenting stockholders can exercise their appraisal rights. The ruling provides valuable guidance for both corporations and stockholders, emphasizing the need to consider the corporation’s financial health before demanding payment for shares.

    For inquiries regarding the application of this ruling to specific circumstances, please contact Atty. Gabriel Ablola through gaboogle.com or via email at connect@gaboogle.com.

    Disclaimer: This analysis is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific legal guidance tailored to your situation, please consult with a qualified attorney.
    Source: PHILIP TURNER AND ELNORA TURNER VS. LORENZO SHIPPING CORPORATION, G.R. No. 157479, November 24, 2010