In-Depth Legal Commentaries, Updates, and Insights
-
Death of an accused pending appeal extinguishes criminal liability in the Philippines. This case illustrates the principle that criminal penalties are personal and cease upon death before final judgment.
-
Executive Judges in extrajudicial foreclosures have ministerial roles, not judicial, and cannot resolve complex debt disputes. Proceeds must be held in trust pending court resolution.
-
SC ruled recipient must return funds mistakenly credited from a bounced check, highlighting ‘solutio indebiti’.
-
In contracts to sell, timely payment is a strict requirement. Failure to pay on time voids the seller’s obligation, though buyers are entitled to a refund to prevent unjust enrichment.
-
Dismissal for just cause was upheld, but procedural lapses led to nominal damages. Employers must ensure due process even with valid grounds for termination.
-
The Supreme Court clarified that ‘unbearable working conditions’ for constructive dismissal must be objectively hostile, not just demanding. It also affirmed that service incentive leave pay prescription starts upon resignation, ensuring employees can claim accrued benefits.
-
Lawyers must diligently monitor cases and comply with court directives; neglect can lead to suspension and client prejudice. Willful disobedience of court orders is gross misconduct.
-
Unlawful detainer is improper if initial entry was contested. Forcible entry, with a one-year limit, or accion publiciana are the correct remedies.