In-Depth Legal Commentaries, Updates, and Insights
-
Accused acquitted due to police mishandling of drug evidence. Chain of custody lapses led to reasonable doubt, emphasizing strict evidence protocols.
-
Supreme Court acquits in drug case due to broken chain of custody. Strict adherence to evidence procedures is crucial for drug convictions.
-
The Supreme Court clarified that informer’s rewards are discretionary, not mandatory, requiring specific, novel information leading to tax revenue recovery, and cannot be compelled by mandamus.
-
Official receipts, not sales invoices, are required for VAT refunds on zero-rated services. Appeals to CTA must be filed within 30 days of BIR inaction to maintain jurisdiction.
-
Positive eyewitness identification, when consistent and credible, outweighs alibi in Philippine courts, as affirmed in Ascarraga murder case.
-
Proof of victim’s age is crucial in statutory rape cases. Insufficient evidence leads to conviction for simple rape, not statutory rape, despite similar penalties.
-
Dismissal of tax appeal for unpaid docket fees is not automatic if there’s no intent to defraud and fees are paid reasonably, especially with initial court error. Taxpayers in good faith are protected.
-
SC clarifies input VAT should not be included in ‘Actual Remaining Construction Cost’ if it’s tax creditable. Prevents double compensation in construction agreements.
-
Philippine Supreme Court upholds corporate separateness, protecting parent firms from subsidiary labor debts absent proven fraud or misuse of corporate veil.