In-Depth Legal Commentaries, Updates, and Insights
-
SC allows late tax appeal due to misleading BIR notice, prioritizing justice over strict rules. Taxpayers may be excused for delays caused by erroneous official instructions.
-
The Supreme Court clarifies the ‘law of the case’ doctrine, affirming that lower courts must adhere to prior appellate rulings but retain power to assess individual liability based on evidence presented after remand.
-
Public officials cannot use ‘good faith’ to excuse violations of procurement laws, especially when it leads to government losses. Strict adherence to procurement rules is crucial.
-
The Supreme Court ruled that the Ombudsman’s intervention in an appeal was untimely because it was filed after the judgment, emphasizing the importance of procedural deadlines even for the Ombudsman.
-
The Supreme Court ruled that a ‘Chief Pathologist’ appointed by a hospital board is not automatically a corporate officer, nor necessarily an employee, impacting jurisdiction in dismissal cases. This highlights the importance of by-laws and control tests in defining employment relationships.
-
Supreme Court upholds conviction of father for qualified rape of his daughter, emphasizing victim’s testimony and familial power dynamics. Delay in reporting in incestuous rape cases does not negate the crime.
-
Reassignments for public school principals without station-specific appointments are valid without consent, prioritizing public service needs over employee preference for location.
-
Acquittal in drug case due to lack of photographic evidence of seized drugs. Highlights importance of procedural adherence in chain of custody for drug cases.
-
The Supreme Court acquitted Rolando Ternida due to the prosecution’s failure to prove chain of custody, specifically the lack of photographs of seized drugs. This highlights the critical need for law enforcers to strictly follow evidence procedures.
-
Lawyer suspended for neglecting client case, highlighting duty of diligence. Negligence in handling legal matters leads to disciplinary action.