In-Depth Legal Commentaries, Updates, and Insights
-
Physician-patient privilege generally bars subpoenaing medical records in civil cases without consent. Timing and waiver are key issues in annulment cases.
-
Dismissal for loss of trust is valid for employees handling funds (fiduciary positions) who incur unexplained shortages. Offsetting is not a valid defense.
-
Compensation for government land taking is based on value at the time of taking, not current value. However, claims don’t expire and earn interest.
-
A judge must independently assess a prosecutor’s motion to withdraw a case and explain the decision in writing. Failure may be challenged via MR or certiorari.
-
Prior possession is crucial in forcible entry cases, even without constant physical presence. Unlawful entry implies the force needed for ejectment.
-
Clarifies self-defense under Philippine law and the key difference between attempted and frustrated homicide: whether the injury was potentially fatal.
-
Unreasonable delays in case investigations violate the constitutional right to speedy disposition. This may lead to dismissal if prejudice is shown.
-
Dismissal for just cause, like breach of trust under Art. 282 of the Labor Code, generally disqualifies an employee from receiving separation pay.
-
A lawyer can claim service fees even after a case’s final judgment, within 6 years for oral contracts. Fees are based on agreement or ‘quantum meruit’.
-
Private agreements generally can’t alter fixed terms of office. Penalizing an association for an unimplemented past agreement requires scrutiny of due process.