In-Depth Legal Commentaries, Updates, and Insights
-
A surety cannot use the principal contract’s arbitration clause as a defense. Surety liability is direct and independent of the principal contract’s dispute resolution methods.
-
The Supreme Court upheld the three-year prescriptive period for tax assessments, protecting taxpayers from stale tax liabilities unless fraud is proven. This case clarifies the limits on the BIR’s power to assess taxes beyond the standard prescriptive period.
-
The Supreme Court protected vulnerable landowners by ruling a ‘sale’ was actually an equitable mortgage. This safeguards against unfair property loss in loan scenarios.
-
Sale or mortgage? SC favors farmers, recognizing ‘sale’ as equitable mortgage due to continued possession and loan intent, protecting vulnerable borrowers.
-
Minor deviations from chain of custody rules in drug cases are acceptable if evidence integrity is preserved. Substantial compliance and justifiable reasons for lapses are key.
-
Supreme Court affirms Ombudsman’s power, upholding probable cause finding against Dichaves for plunder. Judicial restraint emphasized in deference to Ombudsman’s prosecutorial mandate.
-
The Supreme Court applied ‘res ipsa loquitur,’ holding Yellow Bus Line liable for a fatal accident as the circumstances implied driver negligence. This shifts the burden to defendants in similar cases to prove their lack of fault.
-
Employers cannot demand new medical certificates arbitrarily for returning employees recovering from illness. Proper medical certification as per Labor Code is required for disease-related dismissals.
-
Supreme Court clarifies that contractors are not entitled to full payment if they fail to fully deliver contracted services, upholding fair compensation and preventing unjust enrichment in construction disputes.
-
Just compensation in expropriation is valued at the time of taking, even if formal proceedings are delayed. Legal interest mitigates delays, but exemplary damages require proof of bad faith.