Dear Atty. Gab,
Musta Atty! My name is Mario Rivera. My wife and I run a small sari-sari store and a carinderia in our neighborhood in Bacoor, Cavite. We’ve always tried our best to be honest taxpayers. Recently, we were shocked to receive a huge tax assessment from the BIR for almost ₱2 million for the years 2021 and 2022. They said it was for deficiency income tax. The amount is unbelievable and seems to be based on pure estimates, as our small businesses could never have earned that much.
The Final Letter of Demand (FLD) was only addressed to me, but now the BIR has sent a notice to our bank to garnish our joint savings account. They also sent a warrant of levy for a small lot that is registered solely under my wife’s name. We are so confused and scared. How can they go after my wife’s property when the final assessment was only sent to me?
We want to appeal this to the Court of Tax Appeals (CTA), but we were told that to stop the BIR from taking our money and property, we have to deposit the ₱2 million with the court or post a surety bond for almost double that amount. We don’t have that kind of money; our entire life savings and the value of our properties combined are not even half of that. It feels like we are being punished without even having a chance to defend ourselves. Is there any way to fight this unfair assessment in court without having to post a bond that is impossible for us to pay? Thank you for your guidance.
Hoping for your advice,
Mario Rivera
Dear Mario,
Thank you for reaching out. I understand the immense stress and anxiety you and your wife are experiencing. Facing a substantial tax assessment and the subsequent collection efforts from the BIR can be incredibly daunting, especially when the required bond to appeal seems insurmountable.
You have raised a very important legal issue. Generally, appealing a tax assessment to the Court of Tax Appeals (CTA) does not automatically stop the BIR from collecting the tax due. To suspend collection, the law requires the taxpayer to either deposit the assessed amount or file a surety bond. However, this rule is not absolute. Philippine jurisprudence provides a crucial exception for taxpayers like you: if the collection methods employed by the BIR are patently illegal or violate your right to due process, the court has the authority to suspend the collection even without the bond. Your situation, particularly the issues regarding the notice to your wife and the basis of the assessment, may fall under this exception.
Challenging Tax Collection: When an Appeal Shouldn’t Require a Bond
The power of the government to collect taxes is essential for its existence, which is why the law provides it with potent tools like summary collection proceedings. The general rule, found in Section 11 of Republic Act No. 1125 (the law creating the CTA), is designed to prevent taxpayers from using appeals as a mere tactic to delay or evade tax payments. It states that an appeal to the CTA shall not suspend the payment, levy, or distraint of a taxpayer’s property.
However, the law itself provides a safeguard. The same section allows the CTA to suspend the collection if it “may jeopardize the interest of the Government and/or the taxpayer,” provided the taxpayer deposits the amount claimed or files a bond. The critical question, which the Supreme Court has clarified over the years, is whether this bond requirement is mandatory in all circumstances. The answer is no.
The courts recognize that requiring a bond can become a tool of injustice if the underlying collection action is itself unlawful. If the BIR fails to follow the mandatory procedures laid down by law, its collection efforts become legally questionable. The Supreme Court has ruled that it would be absurd for a court to first find that the BIR’s collection method is illegal, and then, in the same breath, require the taxpayer to post a bond as a condition for stopping that same illegal act. This vital principle protects a citizen’s constitutional right to due process.
“It would certainly be an absurdity on the part of the Court of Tax Appeals to declare that the collection by the summary methods of distraint and levy was violative of the law, and then, on the same breath require the petitioner to deposit or file a bond as a prerequisite of the issuance of a writ of injunction.”
This means that if you can demonstrate to the CTA that the BIR’s actions are “patently in violation of the law,” you have strong grounds to ask the court to stop the collection without requiring you to post the prohibitive bond. What constitutes a patent violation? It refers to clear and obvious disregard for legal requirements. In your case, several red flags are apparent. First, the failure to issue a Final Decision on Disputed Assessment (FDDA) or a final assessment notice to your wife is a serious procedural lapse. Due process requires that any person be notified of a claim against them before their property can be taken. Since the warrant of levy targets a property solely in your wife’s name, she must have been accorded her own right to contest the assessment, which starts with proper notice.
Second, an assessment cannot be arbitrary. A taxpayer must be informed of the law and the facts on which the assessment is made. An assessment based on mere “estimates” without factual basis can be considered void.
“An assessment, in order to stand judicial scrutiny, must be based on facts. The presumption of the correctness of an assessment, being a mere presumption, cannot be made to rest on another presumption.”
The CTA has the power to review not just the final decision of the BIR, but also other matters arising under the tax code, which includes the legality of its collection methods. The law gives the court the discretion to protect the taxpayer’s interests when they are jeopardized by unlawful government action.
“…whenever it is determined by the courts that the method employed by the Collector of Internal Revenue in the collection of tax is not sanctioned by law, the bond requirement under Section 11 of R.A. No. 1125 should be dispensed with.”
Therefore, your strategy should focus on convincing the CTA, at the earliest stage, that the BIR’s actions are so procedurally flawed that they constitute a patent violation of your and your wife’s due process rights. By doing so, you can invoke the exception and argue that the bond requirement should be waived, allowing you to have your day in court without having to meet an impossible financial condition.
Practical Advice for Your Situation
- File an Urgent Motion with the CTA: When you file your appeal (Petition for Review) with the CTA, you must simultaneously file an “Urgent Motion to Suspend Collection of Tax.” In this motion, clearly state your request to be exempted from posting a bond.
- Highlight the Due Process Violations: Emphasize that the collection is “patently illegal.” Your strongest argument is the lack of a final assessment notice (like an FLD or FDDA) served to your wife, which is a fundamental denial of her right to due process before her property is levied.
- Question the Arbitrary Assessment: Challenge the basis of the assessment itself. State that it is based on mere “estimates” and not on facts or law, which makes the assessment void and any collection effort based on it illegal.
- Request a Preliminary Hearing: Ask the CTA to conduct a preliminary hearing specifically to determine if the BIR’s collection methods are legal. This allows you to present evidence of the procedural lapses early on, which can be the basis for the court to waive the bond requirement.
- Argue the Impossibility of the Bond: While the primary argument is illegality, you should also demonstrate to the court that the bond amount is confiscatory and prohibitive, effectively denying you your right to appeal. Submit your Statement of Assets, Liabilities, and Net Worth (SALN) or other financial documents to prove this.
- Propose an Alternative, if Necessary: If the court is hesitant to completely waive the bond, you can argue in the alternative that the amount should be drastically reduced to a reasonable and non-prohibitive sum that you can afford.
- Engage a Tax Law Specialist: The rules of procedure in the CTA are complex. It is highly advisable to seek the help of a lawyer specializing in taxation who can draft the proper legal arguments and represent you effectively in court.
Your situation is a classic example of why legal safeguards exist. The power to tax is not the power to destroy. By asserting your rights and pointing out the procedural flaws in the BIR’s actions, you can fight for a just and fair resolution.
Hope this helps!
Sincerely,
Atty. Gabriel Ablola
For more specific legal assistance related to your situation, please contact me through gaboogle.com or via email at connect@gaboogle.com.
Disclaimer: This correspondence is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific legal guidance tailored to your situation, please schedule a formal consultation.

Leave a Reply