Dear Atty. Gab
Musta Atty?
I am writing to you today because I have a confusing legal issue regarding a brand name I’ve been using for my small business selling handmade leather goods in my province for about fifteen years now. Let’s call my brand “LeatherCraft Originals”. It’s not registered with the IPO, but I have loyal customers and have been using it consistently.
About ten years ago, someone based in Metro Manila, let’s call him Mr. Dela Vega, registered a very similar name, “LeatherCraft PH”, for comparable goods. I was worried back then but didn’t have the resources to contest it. However, I recently found out that Mr. Dela Vega’s trademark registration expired a few years ago because he failed to file some required document called a “Declaration of Actual Use” with the Intellectual Property Office.
Now, I want to finally register my brand, “LeatherCraft Originals”. But Mr. Dela Vega is telling people that even though his registration expired, he still has rights to “LeatherCraft” because he continued using it after the registration lapsed. He says I cannot register my mark because it’s confusingly similar to his, which he claims he still owns.
Atty. Gab, I am really confused. If his registration expired because he didn’t follow the rules, does he still own the mark? Can he prevent me from registering my brand, which I’ve been using even before he got his (now expired) registration? What should I do next?
Thank you for your time and any guidance you can offer.
Sincerely,
Maria Hizon
Dear Maria Hizon
Thank you for reaching out and sharing your situation. It’s understandable why you’re confused; trademark law can be complex, especially when dealing with expired registrations and claims of prior use. Your situation touches upon important principles regarding how trademark rights are acquired and maintained in the Philippines.
In simple terms, while registration provides certain advantages, actual ownership of a trademark is fundamentally rooted in its prior use in commerce. The lapsing of a registration due to failure to comply with requirements, such as filing the Declaration of Actual Use, can indeed have significant consequences for the registrant’s rights, potentially paving the way for others who have valid claims based on use.
Understanding Trademark Ownership and Registration
Under Philippine law, particularly the framework that applied to older registrations like the one you mentioned (Republic Act No. 166, and now the Intellectual Property Code), trademark rights are not solely created by registration. While registration offers a presumption of ownership and the exclusive right to use the mark, the underlying right to own and use a trademark originates from its adoption and actual use in trade or business.
The law mandates that registered trademarks must be actively used in commerce. To prove continued use and maintain the validity of a registration obtained under RA 166, registrants were required to file an affidavit (Declaration of Actual Use or DAU) at specific intervals, including the 10th year anniversary of registration. Failure to file this required declaration leads to the automatic cancellation of the trademark registration.
Section 12 of RA 166 states: “That registrations under the provisions of this Act shall be cancelled by the Director, unless within one year following the fifth, tenth and fifteenth anniversaries of the date of issue of the certificate of registration, the registrant shall file in the Patent Office an affidavit showing that the mark or trade-name is still in use… and pay the required fee.”
The cancellation of a trademark registration due to failure to file the DAU is significant. It is considered an abandonment or withdrawal of any right or interest the registrant had over the mark under that specific registration. Once cancelled, that particular registration no longer serves as valid proof of rights or exclusivity.
The failure to file the DAU within the requisite period results in the automatic cancellation of registration of a trademark. In turn, such failure is tantamount to the abandonment or withdrawal of any right or interest the registrant has over his trademark.
However, the other party’s claim is based on their continued use despite the cancellation. This brings us back to the principle that ownership stems from use. But which use prevails? The law recognizes that it is the ownership of a trademark that confers the right to register, not the other way around.
It must be emphasized that registration of a trademark, by itself, is not a mode of acquiring ownership. If the applicant is not the owner of the trademark, he has no right to apply for its registration. Registration merely creates a prima facie presumption of the validity of the registration, of the registrant’s ownership of the trademark, and of the exclusive right to the use thereof. Such presumption… is rebuttable and must give way to evidence to the contrary.
In a conflict scenario, evidence of prior and continuous actual use by one party can overcome the presumption of ownership that a registration (even a subsisting one, though in your case, it’s cancelled) provides to another party. The law aims to protect the true owner of a mark, which is typically the one who first used it in commerce. The claim by Mr. Dela Vega that he continued using the mark after cancellation might be relevant in some contexts, but it doesn’t automatically reinstate his expired registration or erase your own rights based on your potentially earlier and continuous use of “LeatherCraft Originals”.
The ownership of a trademark is acquired by its registration and its actual use by the manufacturer or distributor… A certificate of registration of a mark… constitutes prima facie evidence… This is because a trademark is a creation of use and belongs to one who first used it in trade or commerce.
Furthermore, if Mr. Dela Vega adopted a mark very similar to one you were already using, especially if he was aware of your prior use or if your mark was already known in your area of business, his adoption might be considered in bad faith, which could further weaken his claim.
To come up with a highly distinct and uncommon mark previously appropriated by another, for use in the same line of business, and without any plausible explanation, is incredible. The field from which a person may select a trademark is practically unlimited. As in all other cases of colorable imitations, the unanswered riddle is why, of the millions of terms and combinations of letters and designs available, [the subsequent user] had to come up with a mark identical or so closely similar… if there was no intent to take advantage of the goodwill generated by the [prior user’s] mark.
Given that his registration is cancelled and you have been using your mark for a longer period, you likely have a stronger claim to ownership based on prior use. The expired registration significantly reduces Mr. Dela Vega’s ability to legally assert rights against you based on that registration.
Practical Advice for Your Situation
- Gather Evidence of Your Use: Compile all possible evidence showing your continuous use of “LeatherCraft Originals” since fifteen years ago. This includes sales records, invoices, advertisements (flyers, social media posts, local newspaper ads), supplier receipts for materials used, customer testimonials, photos of your products with the branding, etc.
- Verify the Cancellation Status: Confirm with the IPO that Mr. Dela Vega’s registration for “LeatherCraft PH” has indeed been cancelled due to failure to file the DAU. You can check the IPO’s online database or contact them directly.
- Proceed with Your Trademark Application: Since the prior registration is cancelled, you should proceed with filing your application for “LeatherCraft Originals” with the IPO. Your claim will be based on your prior and continuous use.
- Prepare to Assert Your Prior Rights: If Mr. Dela Vega opposes your application, you will need to formally present the evidence of your earlier and continuous use to the IPO to prove your ownership and right to register. His cancelled registration will be less of a barrier for you now.
- Consider Legal Representation: Navigating the IPO process, especially in the face of potential opposition, can be challenging. Hiring a lawyer specializing in intellectual property can significantly improve your chances of successful registration and help you effectively assert your rights based on your prior use.
- Address Bad Faith (If Applicable): If you have reason to believe Mr. Dela Vega was aware of your use when he registered his mark, this could be a point to raise during the opposition proceedings, as it speaks to his good faith in adopting the mark.
Hope this helps!
Sincerely,
Atty. Gabriel Ablola
For more specific legal assistance related to your situation, please contact me through gaboogle.com or via email at connect@gaboogle.com.
Disclaimer: This correspondence is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific legal guidance tailored to your situation, please schedule a formal consultation.

Leave a Reply