Why Were Our Company’s Financial Records Disregarded in the Wage Arbitration?

Dear Atty. Gab

Musta Atty?

I hope this email finds you well. My name is Alfredo Fernandez, and I’m a long-time employee and union member at ‘Protek Manufacturing Corp.’. We recently went through a difficult collective bargaining negotiation, and after reaching a deadlock on wages and benefits, the Secretary of Labor assumed jurisdiction over our dispute because our company was deemed important to the national interest. We presented our demands, and the company presented theirs, largely based on financial statements their internal accountant prepared, showing they couldn’t afford our proposed increases.

When the Secretary of Labor issued the arbitral award, the wage increase was much lower than we expected. Our union leaders told us that the Secretary somehow questioned the company’s financial statements during the process, even though the company insisted they were accurate and signed by their head accountant. The company argues these statements are official and were even submitted to government agencies.

We are very confused. If the company’s own financial statements, signed by their accountant, aren’t reliable enough for the Secretary of Labor, what kind of financial evidence is needed in these arbitration cases? Does this mean the company wasn’t being truthful about its capacity to pay? We just want to understand why their numbers weren’t accepted and how the wage award was decided based on potentially incomplete financial information.

Any guidance you could provide on this matter would be greatly appreciated. Thank you for your time and expertise.

Sincerely,

Alfredo Fernandez

Dear Alfredo Fernandez

Musta Atty!

Thank you for reaching out and sharing the details of your situation. It’s understandable to feel confused and frustrated when the basis for a crucial decision like a wage award in compulsory arbitration isn’t clear, especially when it involves financial data presented by your employer. Your concern about the reliability of the financial statements and the process used by the Secretary of Labor is valid and touches upon important legal principles regarding evidence and administrative procedure in labor disputes.

In compulsory arbitration cases, particularly those where the Secretary of Labor steps in due to national interest concerns, the determination of a fair wage award requires careful consideration of various factors, including the employer’s financial capacity. The law and jurisprudence provide guidance on the type of evidence needed to accurately assess this capacity, ensuring fairness to both the employees seeking a just share in the company’s profits and the employer needing reasonable returns and growth.

Establishing Financial Capacity in Labor Arbitration

When the Secretary of Labor assumes jurisdiction over a labor dispute causing or likely to cause a strike or lockout in an industry indispensable to the national interest, this authority includes the power to decide the dispute through compulsory arbitration. This means the Secretary effectively resolves the collective bargaining deadlock, including setting the terms for wages and benefits. A crucial aspect of determining fair wages is understanding the company’s financial health and its capacity to absorb wage increases. The financial statements of the employer are often presented as key evidence for this purpose.

However, not just any financial statement will suffice, particularly in a formal arbitration setting before the Secretary of Labor. The law requires evidence to meet certain standards of admissibility and probative value. When it comes to proving a company’s financial condition, unaudited financial statements, even if prepared and signed by the company’s internal accountant or chief financial officer, may be considered insufficient. This is because such statements lack independent verification.

“without the accompanying signature of a certified public accountant or audited by an independent auditor, are nothing but self-serving documents which ought to be treated as a mere scrap of paper devoid of any probative value.”

As established by jurisprudence, statements of profit and loss or other financial reports not audited by an independent auditor are seen merely as self-serving documents. They do not carry the weight of evidence needed to conclusively prove the financial capacity, or lack thereof, of a company, especially when that capacity is being contested in a legal or quasi-judicial proceeding like compulsory arbitration. While these might be submitted to government agencies for other purposes, their evidentiary value in a dispute over wages and benefits requires a higher standard.

This principle applies not only to cases involving business closure or retrenchment due to losses but also to wage determination in compulsory arbitration. The reasoning is consistent: to protect the rights of labor to a just share in the fruits of production and to ensure employers do not understate profitability to defeat this right, the financial information presented as evidence must be verified by an independent party. An audit performed by an external and independent auditor provides that necessary layer of verification, making the financial statements admissible and reliable evidence for determining a company’s capacity to pay.

“While the rules of evidence prevailing in the courts of law or equity are not controlling in proceedings before the NLRC, the evidence presented before it must at least have a modicum of admissibility for it to be given some probative value.”

Therefore, relying solely on unaudited financial statements, even if certified internally, can constitute grave abuse of discretion on the part of the decision-maker because such evidence is considered self-serving and inadmissible for proving financial capacity in this context. The Secretary of Labor, in making a wage award, must properly consider and appreciate the evidence presented, which necessitates the use of reliable financial data.

Furthermore, administrative due process requires that decisions, especially those affecting rights and obligations, must clearly state the factual and legal bases. When a wage award is made in compulsory arbitration, the decision should articulate the factors considered, such as bargaining history, industry trends, and the company’s capacity to pay (based on properly audited financials), and explain how these factors led to the specific award. Merely stating that certain factors were considered without detailing the actual data or computations can fall short of this requirement, making it difficult for parties to understand the decision’s rationale.

“administrative due process obligating the decision-maker to adjudicate the rights of the parties in such a manner that they can know the various issues involved and the reasons for the decision rendered.”

This ensures transparency and allows parties to determine if the decision was reasonable and supported by evidence. In some cases, if the Secretary of Labor’s decision is based on unreliable evidence or lacks a clear explanation of its basis, a higher court may find grave abuse of discretion and order the case remanded for re-determination using proper evidence, such as audited financial statements.

It’s also important to note that in collective bargaining and compulsory arbitration, any terms that the parties had already agreed upon during negotiations generally cannot be altered or reduced by the Secretary of Labor unless there is a compelling legal reason. Agreements reached on specific benefits, for instance, should typically be incorporated into the final arbitral award.

Practical Advice for Your Situation

  • Understand that in compulsory arbitration before the Secretary of Labor, a company’s financial capacity to pay is a key factor.
  • Know that unaudited financial statements submitted by the company, even if certified internally, are generally considered self-serving and may lack probative value in determining this capacity.
  • The Secretary of Labor should base the assessment of financial capacity on properly audited financial statements prepared by an external, independent auditor.
  • If the arbitral award’s basis on financial capacity seems unclear or appears based on questionable unaudited data, the union may have grounds to question the award.
  • Decisions in compulsory arbitration must comply with administrative due process, meaning they should clearly explain the factual and legal bases for the award, including how financial evidence was considered.
  • Any provisions or amounts previously agreed upon by the union and management during negotiations should ordinarily be upheld in the final arbitral award.
  • Consult with your union leaders or legal counsel to review the specific documents and the Secretary of Labor’s decision to determine if proper procedures and evidence standards were followed.

Based on what you’ve described, it seems the Secretary of Labor may have indeed found the company’s unaudited financial statements insufficient, which is in line with established legal principles regarding evidence in labor cases. The subsequent wage award would then need to be justified based on other available, reliable evidence, or the matter might need further clarification or re-determination.

Hope this helps!

Sincerely,
Atty. Gabriel Ablola

For more specific legal assistance related to your situation, please contact me through gaboogle.com or via email at connect@gaboogle.com.

Disclaimer: This correspondence is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific legal guidance tailored to your situation, please schedule a formal consultation.

About the Author

Atty. Gabriel Ablola is a member of the Philippine Bar. Gaboogle is his personal blog where he shares legal analysis and commentary on Philippine law, covering areas such as Maritime Law, Corporate Law, Taxation Law, and Constitutional Law.

For professional legal services and inquiries, Atty. Ablola may be reached through ASG Law Partners at www.asglawpartners.com or gca@asglawpartners.com.

Other Posts

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *